Motorhead Quote

"The battlefields are silent now. The graves all look the same." -- Motorhead,Voices from the War

Saturday, December 10, 2022

Farewell Fred

I lost a close friend over Thanksgiving weekend. Frederic C. Wagner III passed away on Sunday, November 27, 2022, at 10:19pm EST. 

Of course his friends never called him Frederic. He was just plain old Fred. He was one of the smartest guys I ever met. He had an uncanny ability to uncover, catalog, and interpret vast amounts of data, He was also one of the kindest and open people I have ever had the pleasure of calling friend.

Fred, Garryowen, MT - 2013

I have also never met anyone as passionate about the Battle of the Little Big Horn as Fred. He wanted to know every small detail about the battle and its participants. And somehow he could remember all that information and be able to recall it. He had collected massive amounts of computer data on everything from vegetation on the battlefield to the walking speed of horses.

When I first met him (Summer 2007), he was lugging around these large three-ring binders and topographic maps. He was working on a timeline for the battle. He had painstakingly entered bits of information into a large spreadsheet and was able to put everything into context and show when certain events happened during the battle. He was always refining those timelines and was eventually able to share them in a book, STRATEGY OF DEFEAT AT THE LITTLE BIG HORN: A MILITARY AND TIMING ANALYSIS OF THE BATTLE. This book shook things up in the study of the battle and has become a time tested standard. Fred also helped write the screenplay for a movie (Strategy of Defeat:The Movie) that was based on the book.

Fred's Books (descriptions from Amazon):

Participants in the Battle of the Little Big Horn: A Biographical Dictionary of Sioux, Cheyenne and United States Military Personnel: The Battle of the Little Big Horn was the decisive engagement of the Great Sioux War of 1876-1877. In its second edition this biographical dictionary of all known participants--the 7th Cavalry, civilians and Indians--provides a brief description of the battle, as well as information on the various tribes, their customs and methods of fighting. Seven appendices cover the units soldiers were assigned to, uniforms and equipment of the cavalry, controversial listings of scouts and the number of Indians in the encampments, the location of camps on the way to the Big Horn and more. Updated biographies are provided for many European soldiers, along with an additional 5,060 names of Indians who were or could have been in the battle.

The Strategy of Defeat at the Little Big Horn: A Military and Timing Analysis of the Battle: The battle that unfolded at the Little Big Horn River on June 25, 1876, marked a watershed in the history of the Plains Indians. While a stunning victory for the Sioux and Cheyenne peoples, it initiated a new and vigorous effort by the U.S. government to rid the west of marauding tribes and to realize the ideal of "Manifest Destiny." While thousands of books and articles have covered different aspects of the battle, few if any have analyzed the tactics and chronology to arrive at a satisfactory explanation of what befell George Armstrong Custer and the 209 men who died alongside him. This volume seeks to explain the circumstances culminating in the near-destruction of the 7th Cavalry Regiment by a close examination of timing, setting every event to a specific moment based on accounts of the battle's participants.

Marcus Reno in the Valley of the Little Big Horn: Limited Means, Excessive Aims: Major Marcus Reno's actions at the Battle of Little Big Horn have been both criticized and lauded, often without in-depth analysis. This book takes a fresh look the battle and events leading up to it, offering answers to unanswered questions. The author examines the meanings of "orders" given in Custer's command and how they were treated, the tactics and fighting in the valley, Reno's alcoholism, and his last stand on the hilltop named for him.

The Great Sioux Campaign of 1876, Day-by-Day: Drawing on more than 22 years' research, this book presents an exhaustive chronology of the Great Sioux Campaign in three parts: the U.S. Seventh Cavalry's communications, decisions and movements October 15, 1875-June 21, 1876, are traced day-by-day; the three-day prelude to the Battle of Little Bighorn hour-by-hour; and the battle itself minute-by-minute. The separate actions of the several military commands and the Indians involved are narrated in coherent sequence. Archival intelligence summaries offer the reader fresh perspective on the events leading to the decisive Indian victory known as Custer's Last Stand.

Back in April 2021 Fred did a presentation for his "valley book" that was uploaded to YouTube. Here is a link to that presentation...


We call our little group of friends Montana Mayhem and you can check out our trip diaries and photo albums by clicking the link below...


Farewell Fred. Garryowen my friend.

3 comments:

  1. This is a great tribute to a kind man. I never met Fred in person, but his Facebook messages were always open for any question, whether about a fact or research tact, that I had. I'll miss his "pushes," forcing online posters to present facts or context to support their theories about the battle. His work will be the foundation that supports future study.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I agree, Pete. I never met Fred, either but I was a huge fan. His standards were as high as they come and he expected the same of other who presented "facts" about Little Bighorn. Thank you for posting this. I will be forever sorry that I didn't discover my passion for this topic sooner in life - I could have met Fred!

    ReplyDelete
  3. Thank you both for the kind words about Fred. He was definitely one of a kind. He forgot more about the Little Big Horn battle than I'll ever know. I sure miss him. He influenced a great number of people who'll miss him as well.

    ReplyDelete

Please feel free to leave your comments. No sign-in required.